Mangroves: 2000 Publications

Author: Walters, B.B.
Title: Local mangrove planting in the Philippines: Are fisherfolk and fishpond owners effective restorationists?
Publication: Restoration Ecology 8(3): 237-246, 2000.
© Blackwell Science

Notes: Local fisherfolk and fishpond owners have been practicing ''restoration'' of mangrove forests in some parts of the Philippines for decades, well before governments and non-government organizations began to promote the activity as a conservation tool. This paper examines ecological characteristics of these mangrove plantations and compares them to natural mangroves in the same areas. Mangrove planters were interviewed and plantation and natural mangrove forests were surveyed to measure forest structure, composition and regeneration. Compared with natural forests, mangrove plantations were characterized by high densities of small stems, shorter and narrower canopies, and fewer species. For both economic and ecological reasons, the vast majority of people dispersed and planted only Rhizophora mucronata/stylosa and, furthermore, they often thinned other species out of planted areas. There was remarkably little subsequent recruitment of other, non-planted mangrove species into plantations up to 50 and 60 years of age. This pattern held across a diversity of sites, including plantations that had not been selectively cut or weeded. Important ecological and economic benefits result from local mangrove planting, but catalyzing diverse forest regeneration - at least in the short to medium term - is not one of them. The lesson: if you want to restore diverse mangrove forests, you have to plant diverse mangrove forests.